A 5 pound pork butt at 225°F takes about 10 to 12 hours if you leave it unwrapped. From about 7 pounds up, this plan slows the rate to about 90 minutes per pound, so an 8 pound butt is also about 10 to 12 hours and a 10 pound butt is about 12 hours 30 minutes to 15 hours. Wrap in foil and you can cut about two hours off, since the wrap stops the surface from cooling itself. The meat is done near 203°F, when the bone wiggles. The timer is only there so you light the fire early enough to reach that feel.

The window

The trim, the rub, the fire, and the pull are how to smoke pork butt. These cook times match the pork butt smoking time calculator. They do not include the 45 minutes to settle the grate or the hour to rest and pull. The first number is the fast end. Light the fire from the second number. A faster cook becomes a longer hold. It does not become an earlier dinner if the bark still needs to settle.

The 5 pound line comes from the Amazing Ribs pulled pork recipe, which lists that butt at 10 to 12 hours around 225°F. The heavier lines use their note of about 90 minutes per pound for an average 6 to 8 pound butt, from their page on cooking more than one piece. Between 5 and 7 pounds the two rates are blended, which is why a 7 pound butt can be scheduled a little shorter in total than a 5 pound one. The per-pound rate dropped. The shoulder did not shrink.

Left open:

Piece225°F250°F275°F
5 lb10–12 hr9–10 hr 30 min8–9 hr
7 lb8 hr 45 min–10 hr 30 min7 hr 45 min–9 hr6 hr 45 min–7 hr 30 min
8 lb10–12 hr9–10 hr 30 min8–9 hr
10 lb12 hr 30 min–15 hr11 hr 30 min–13 hr 30 min10 hr 30 min–12 hr

Tight foil, about two hours under the open window at the same grate:

Piece225°F250°F275°F
5 lb8–10 hr7–8 hr 30 min6–7 hr
7 lb6 hr 45 min–8 hr 30 min5 hr 45 min–7 hr4 hr 45 min–5 hr 30 min
8 lb8–10 hr7–8 hr 30 min6–7 hr
10 lb10 hr 30 min–13 hr9 hr 30 min–11 hr 30 min8 hr 30 min–10 hr

Outside 4 to 8 pounds, treat the clock as a rough start and trust the bone.

Pink butcher paper is not the foil table. Paper breathes, so it will not shave the full two hours. If you plan to use paper, start closer to the open window than to the foil one.

Time per pound

At 225°F, unwrapped, a 5 pound butt is about 2 hours per pound on the fast end and about 2.4 hours per pound on the slow end. That is just the 10 and 12 hour recipe written as a rate. From 7 pounds up, the slow end is 90 minutes per pound and the fast end is 75 minutes per pound, the same 10-to-12 ratio kept on the heavier piece. A 10 pound butt is therefore about 12 hours 30 minutes to 15 hours, not 20 to 24. Using the 5 pound rate on a heavy butt makes you light the fire in the middle of the night for a cook that was never that long.

Hotter pits are a cut in hours, not a new per-pound slogan. At 250°F this plan takes about 1 hour off the fast end and about 1 hour 30 minutes off the slow end. At 275°F it takes about 2 hours off the fast end and about 3 hours off the slow end. That 2 to 4 hour idea is the published note that a pit near 275°F can shorten a 225°F shoulder. This site takes the smaller cut off the fast end so that end still finishes first.

The stall is plotted at about one third of the slow 225°F cook, then shortened if the pit is hotter. On a 5 pound or 8 pound butt at 225°F that mark is around 4 hours, near 150°F in the meat. It is a planning mark, not a buzzer. Shape, wind, and a cold butt straight from the fridge all move it.

What else moves the clock

Weight is the input. Thickness still matters. Two butts with the same sticker can finish an hour apart if one is a tall lump and the other is flat. A boneless roast is often smaller once the bone is gone, and it can finish sooner. Bone-in is the usual piece, and the bone is also the doneness test, so that is the shoulder this clock is written for.

A grate that is hotter than you think shortens the cook and dries the edges. On a kamado the lid gauge sits in the dome and usually runs hotter than the meat. The number in this plan is a probe at cooking height. Give the pit about 45 minutes before the butt goes on, the same buffer as a packer. Meat thermometers for smoking is how to pick the probe that has to stay in for the whole cook. The grate and the meat together are on best meat thermometer for smoking.

Wrapping early, before the bark has color, saves time and steams the crust. Wrapping late, or not at all, keeps the bark and spends the hours in the table. A crowded pit, a windy day, or a lid you open every twenty minutes to look all push the slow end. Build the day from that slow end.

With sides on the table, a third to a half pound of cooked pork is a normal plate, which means closer to three quarters of a pound raw. Bone and the long cook take weight off. If the butt is the whole meal, buy a full half pound cooked per adult and plan on leftovers. Leftover pulled pork is a better problem than a short tray.

Choose and trim

Buy a bone-in Boston butt. Packages often say pork shoulder for the same upper piece, and this clock treats those labels as one cook. A picnic is the lower shoulder. It usually still has the skin and the hock, and it is a different shape. If that is what you brought home, use the calculator as a start and let the feel decide the end.

Leave a thin fat cap. Trim only the hard, waxy pieces that will not render, and any loose flaps that will burn before the center is close. You do not need to sculpture a shoulder the way you trim a packer. The fat that is left bastes the outside and becomes part of the bark you mix back in at the end. Pat it dry so the rub sticks in an even coat instead of clumps.

The rub

Use the pork butt rub. Half a cup of Diamond Crystal, a quarter cup each of paprika and coarse pepper, granulated garlic, onion powder, and one tablespoon of brown sugar. That spoon of sugar is for color on a long cook. A sweeter rib rub can darken until the bark tastes bitter by the time the bone lets go. Morton salt needs the smaller measure on the rub page, about a third of a cup, because the crystals are denser.

The brisket rub will season a butt, and it will taste like salt and pepper. Pork has room for the paprika. Coat the whole surface, including the ends. Piling it on does not salt the inside any faster. A few hours uncovered in the fridge dries the surface. Same-day works. Put the probe in thick meat, away from the bone, after the rub is on. Bone conducts heat, so a probe against it reads hotter than the pork you will actually pull, and the cook looks finished early.

The stall

The temperature will sit near 150°F. Water evaporating off the surface cools the meat as fast as a 225°F pit can heat it. The fire is usually fine. The full why is pork butt stall. On a 5 pound butt at 225°F the plan plots that pause around 4 hours in. Your graph can arrive earlier or later. The color of the bark matters more than the minute.

Check the grate before you open the vents. A falling grate is a fire problem. A steady grate and a flat line near 150°F is the stall. Spraying the surface adds water, which is the thing causing the pause, so a heavy spritz can stretch it. If the bark already looks like the pork you meant to eat, leave it alone.

Leave it unwrapped

Unwrapped is the full window in the table and the firmer bark. The paprika crust keeps drying in the pit instead of steaming in a packet. A 5 pound or 8 pound butt at 225°F is the 10 to 12 hour cook, then an hour to rest. You picked that when you set the alarm, not when the graph went flat and the afternoon felt long.

Pros

  • The bark stays drier, which is the part people want mixed back through the pull.
  • You are not guessing whether the color was set enough to survive a packet.

Cons

  • You keep the whole window, including a stall that can sit for hours.
  • If the day got away from you, there is no two-hour foil lever left.

Wrap in foil

A tight foil wrap, the Texas crutch, can cut about two hours off both ends of this plan. Do it when the bark is set and the center is near 160°F. The stall itself shows up nearer 150°F. Wrapping at 150°F while the surface is still pale softens a crust that never formed. The decision, in that order, is when to wrap pork butt.

Tight means a packet, not a loose tent. A tent leaks steam and does not buy the two hours. Leave the probe in thick meat if you can close the foil around it. The calculator's wrap switch is this foil cut. Paper will not match it.

Pros

  • Two hours is a real cut when a 5 pound butt was planned at 10 to 12 hours and guests moved the meal up.
  • The stall ends because the surface can no longer cool itself.

Cons

  • Foil bark is softer. Shards of crust were the other plan.
  • An early wrap, while the rub is still pale, tastes steamed instead of smoked.

Wrap in pink butcher paper

Paper is the middle path. It blocks some airflow, so the cook moves a bit faster than a naked butt, and it lets steam out, so the bark survives better than it does in foil. It will not take the full two hours off. If you start at the foil time and wrap in paper, you run late. Two layers, seams down. Freezer paper has a plastic coating and is the wrong roll. The comparison, including the brisket hours that do not copy onto pork one-for-one, is butcher paper vs foil.

Pros

  • You keep more of the paprika crust than foil leaves you.
  • You still get a little help through the stall without sealing the butt in.

Cons

  • Paper is not the foil clock. The two-hour cut in the table is the tight foil wrap.
  • A loose sheet does almost nothing, and you have handled the meat for no time saved.

When it will pull

Pull around 203°F in the thick meat, then check the shoulder. On a bone-in butt the blade should wiggle free with little force. On a boneless roast a fork should twist with almost no pressure. Most butts give up somewhere in the low 200s, and every shoulder is a little different. If the probe reads 203°F and the bone still holds, wait. If it lets go a few degrees earlier, pull it. The number gets you to the neighborhood. The bone is the test. That feel is internal temp for pulled pork.

It is safe to eat long before it will shred. At 165°F or even 180°F the connective tissue is still tight, and you tear it into chunks. The strands people mean by pulled pork show up after that tissue softens. Do not chase a slicing temperature on a butt you meant to pull. If you truly want slices, take it earlier, while it still holds together, and accept that it will not shred.

A wireless probe that dies inside foil is a signal problem, not a finished shoulder. The steps are Meater not connecting. A wired probe from the thermometer notes does not care about the packet.

Rest, then pull

Rest about an hour before you pull the pork, and keep it at or above 140°F if it has to wait longer. The wrap can stay on. Start shredding about half an hour before you serve, so the pork is hot and the bark is still worth mixing through it. Shredding at noon for a 5 p.m. plate leaves it drying on the counter.

Pull by hand, or with two forks, and mix the crust back through the meat. The bark is the seasoned part. If you pile naked shreds in a pan and leave the crust on the board, the pork tastes boiled. A splash of the juices from the packet brings it back if the edges look dry. Sauce is optional, and it should not be covering up a butt that never got tender.

An early finish is a longer hold, which the calculator already labels. It is not a reason to shred early and leave the pan out.

When the cook goes sideways

The hour in the table is a plan. The butt in front of you is the cook. Run through these before you turn the pit up or wrap out of nerves.

The temperature sits still and the grate is steady. That is the stall. Wait for color, or wrap if you want the two-hour foil cut. Opening the vents "to push through" raises the pit while the surface is still evaporating, and the edges dry before the center moves.

The temperature sits still and the grate is dropping. That is the fire. A kamado with a choked vent looks exactly like a stall until you measure at the grate. Fix the fire. Foil will not invent heat that is not there.

The probe says it is done and the bone is tight. You are touching bone, or you are in a hot spot near the edge. Move the probe to the thick middle. The bone test still wins.

The bark is pale after the wrap. You wrapped too early. The next butt waits until the color is set, closer to 160°F than to the first flat line at 150°F. Opening the packet at the end of the rest dries the surface a little. It does not rebuild bark.

It is hours early. Hold it above 140°F and shred closer to dinner. It is hours late. Check that you did not start on the foil clock and then use paper, and that the grate was the dome gauge instead of the cooking height. The meat can still finish. Dinner moves. A tough pull at 185°F is worse than a late one.

The shreds are dry chunks. It came off too early, or the probe was in the wrong place and you believed it. Put it back, covered, until a fork twists. Sauce hides this for one bite.

The bark is bitter. Too much sugar for a cook this long. The pork butt rub uses one tablespoon on purpose. A rib rub is a different jar and a shorter piece of meat.

Set the start on the pork butt smoking time calculator, mix the rub, and keep the technique pages for the stall and the wrap once the lid is down. The brisket clock is a different piece of meat. A packer slogan will not tell you when this shoulder is ready to pull.